Search This Blog

Friday, March 4, 2011

The Fisher and Paykel Aquasmart washer: a washing machine ahead of its time or a prototype pretending to be the finished product? (A review of the Fisher and Paykel Aquasmart washing machine)


Machine type:
High efficiency top loader, capacity 7kg


Australian models:

8kg WL80T65CW1
7kg WL70T60CW1

US models:

3.7 cu ft WL37T26CW2
4.2 cu ft WL42T26CW1
4.2 cu ft WL42T26DW1 
4.2 cu ft WL42T26DW1 
4.2 cu ft WL42T26KW1 

Before we start, it's important to understand that this machine works differently
from other top loaders. The fact that you must use High efficiency or front loading low
sudsing detergent should alert you to this fact. The machine uses about the
same amount of water per wash as a front loader, although for some cycles such
as delicate items, it uses a full load of water. You can also choose to
manually override the Aquasmart
 (low water setting) and force the machine to use a conventional wash.

You’ll also notice that there’s no agitator – highly unusual for a top loading washer. The clothes are washed by gently tossing them over in the bowl, rather than around the agitator.

Washing modes

On the LCD model, there’s a mind boggling number of washing modes, ranging from a regular wash to a shoes wash mode. Yes, shoes. Among the so called “Lifestyle Cycles”, there are also separate wash modes for chocolate, blood, tomato, grass, fruit and wine. In the Sport section, there are modes for sweaty, muddy, sports shoes and beach gear. This is just scratching the surface – there are many more cycles, for almost every imaginable washing situation. Are they just a marketing gimmick, or do they actually work? According to the instruction manual,

“These cycles have been specifically designed by our washing experts, with you in mind.
We have incorporated 70 years of washing knowledge into 19 easy to use, preprogrammed wash
cycles. This allows you to let the washer deal with some of the more tricky washing situations
you may encounter, ensuring that you get the same results as a washing expert, without having
to be one.”

Hmmm. I think that as with any stain, if you treat it quickly by hand first, and then wash it, the machine will do its job. Don’t expect it to remove a two day old food stain though.

User interface

Backlit LCD screen is easy to read
The machine has an LCD display screen with buttons to set your washing program. The LCD is backlit, which is great in low light, but strangely the buttons aren’t backlit. It would have been nice to have both. The button panel is placed to the right of the display, and it’s a little awkward to use, as you have to look back at the display to make sure you’ve made the right selections. I feel that it would have been better located under the display. Sometimes I find myself touching the screen, which has large, bright, pulsating icons, almost inviting you to touch them – maybe the next model will add a touchscreen.

Each button press is signalled by a beep, but you can turn this off if you wish. The end of wash cycle can also be set to beep – 5 or 15 times. Personally, I think five beeps is too little and 15 too many. Why not 10?

The machine's lint removal system means that you MUST separate lint givers (fleecy items such as track pants) from lint receivers (for example, cotton t shirts), and it is very fussy about this, especially in regard to black or
dark coloured clothing. For example, if you wash a pair of black fleecy track pants with a dark blue t shirt, the chances are pretty good that the t shirt will be covered in lint. However, if you wash your fleecy lint givers separately from your t shirts, you  generally won't have a 
problem. This takes some adjustment if you’re used to throwing everything in together! There’s no lint trap at all in the machine, and F&P claims that lint is extracted and removed with the grey water during the wash. Not if you wash the wrong types of clothes together though!

Powder or liquid detergent?

Use a good quality liquid detergent
for best results
Even when using good quality powder detergent (the same brand included as a sample when I bought the machine, Cussons Radiant powder), I’ve found that when using a high efficiency wash in combination with dark colored clothing can cause powder residue to be left on the clothes after a wash. There are 2 solutions to this problem – use the conventional wash mode, or use a good quality liquid detergent.

Conventional wash – This seems to be the go to mode when the High Efficiency mode doesn’t produce good results. It adds more water, but not as much as a conventional top loader, so in theory you’re still saving water! Using a liquid detergent seems to go a long way to reducing any residue problems you might have with powder detergents.

There is also an “aqua plus” mode, which adds more water to the rinse cycle in high efficiency mode. I have set this to “on” permanently, so that the lint/residue problems are minimised. The operating manual also suggests as much:

“Activating this option adds additional water to the Aqua rinse in a High
Efficiency wash cycle. This will give you a little extra rinsing for those with
sensitive skin. You can also use this option if you tend to wash lot of dark
garments.”

Most settings can be customised in this way. For example, you can set the spin speed to medium or slow by default if you don’t like a fast spin. You can also change the default temperature of cold, warm and hot washes. Washing “hints” are also turned on by default, and can be turned off when you are used to the machine.
Get used to seeing this message

When washing items that can become very heavy when wet, such as large sheets or quilt covers, the machine sometimes goes out of balance when spinning and stops. Although it comes with an automatic out of balance correction 
feature which adds extra water to attempt to float the load if this happens, this feature is turned off by default! I would strongly suggest that you turn this on in order to minimise this problem. I say minimise, because it doesn’t eliminate the issue. There have been times when I’ve come home after leaving a wash and heard the dreaded F&P alert tone. This means that the machine has tried, but failed to redistribute the load, so you have to do it manually and try again – and again sometimes! This gets annoying quickly.
What’s the reason for it happening? It seems that the lack of an agitator has something to do with it. Because the sheet is tossed over itself, it can end up in the shape of a ball – a large, heavy ball. This thumps around inside the washing compartment, and causes the machine to go out of balance. It’s not unusual for the whole machine to have moved from its original position during this process, and the noise can be disconcerting at first!

Even with a small load there can
be out of balance issues
I would go as far as saying that this is a design fault, and that you should be aware that if you buy this machine, you’re going to run into the out of balance problem at some point. It doesn’t happen with every load, but just make sure you flatten large sheets and quilts when you put them into the machine. Don’t just jam them in, and follow the instruction book when determining how many you should wash in one load. In my 7kg machine, one king size, or two queen size sheets is about the limit, or one king/queen size quilt. If the load works itself into a ball, it’s almost certain that you’re going to hear that dreaded alert tone at some stage.

You have to give FP credit for attempting to introduce a completely new type of washer, but in practice, the concept doesn’t quite come together. I’m used to throwing everything into the machine, pushing a button or two, and walking away. You just can’t do that with the Aquasmart. You have to think about what you’re doing. Can I wash this with that, should I use a slower spin speed, oh yeah, it’s a sheet, I have to unfurl it first. Being more than slightly geeky, I like to tinker to find the right settings for each type of load. But I understand that most people don’t want to do this. My wife, for instance. She just gives me the load and says “here, you do it”. Get used to hearing that if you buy this machine! It works quite well, but requires some effort on your part. You must read the manual, and you must be prepared to experiment with its settings until the wash is to your satisfaction.

Agree…disagree with this review? Have something to add? Feel free to comment!

17 comments:

  1. A very informative blog, especially today as it beeps error code 246 when it spins. I love being able to adjust all the settings but can't stand having to always rebalance so good tip on the 'out of balance'..And don't use Aldies washing powder.. does not like it. fromonemumtoanother.blogspot.com.au

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wrote a lot of the sense firmware for this machine, and your review is pretty close to my own thoughts on the AquaSmart. I loved how well the direct drive system spun the clothes and cut my energy and water usage. I disliked that it wrung jeans so well that I used to "snap" them before loading into the dryer. Perhaps a small price to pay for cutting my dry time and energy bill by a third or more?
    I guess I could have turned the spin down.. ;)

    Oh, and the detergent problems are not just with washing machines these days. My dishwasher and dishes have suffered due to new regulations on Phosphate. I do recommend a liquid detergent for this machine. Also, don't ball up sheets, coats and the like. I put a lot of thought into the firmware for that particular problem, but it is still a problem. On very small loads, wash items of a like fabric type, turn the spin speed way down, or choose conventional to avoid balance issues.

    There are pros and cons of this technology, it's still pretty new. When I used it, I noticed I washed clothes differently, but I could wash large loads of clothes faster. Some people like it (including a B&B place that ran the machine in a commercial setting for years) Others hate it because it's different and they won't change their washing habits.

    The F&P top load horizontal drum dryer is another innovate piece. Standard front load dryers and the restrictive hole of the small door opening solved, and hard to go back to, for me at least. Less bending over as well.

    Compared to my wife's beloved LG frontloader set, I wish I still had the Fisher and Paykel prototypes.

    -Mike

    ReplyDelete
  3. I HATE my fisher paykel and am looking for one without balancing issues!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Fisher & Paykel have designed an item (The Aquasmart) and are proud to receive the money and get wealthy.If they had any considerations for their Aquasmart customers, they would RECALL all of them and REFUND their money.
    The F&P company may be great, but when you have a failure at least have the guts to admit it and rectify it honestly and proudly.
    If motor vehicle companies have to do this , why should it be any different.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sorry to say that I am extremely disappointed with this washer. I've used every type of higher priced liquid detergent and there is ALWAYS a white residue on all of my dark clothes. Many times I wind up washing the load again with no detergent just to get the residue off. I also do not like the fact that you cannot use bleach in these washers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've managed to overcome this problem by using a liquid detergent (stay right away from powder) and setting the aquasave mode to "aqua plus" (this adds a little extra water to the high efficiency mode).

      Since doing this, I haven't had any residue on my black clothes, and I'm very fussy about how they look!

      Delete
  6. Thіѕ іs rеally intereѕting,
    You are a νery skilleԁ blοgger. I have jοined
    youг feed and look forwагd to seekіng more οf your
    excellent post. Also, I hаve ѕhared уour
    webѕіte іn my social networks!
    Also visit my web-site :: A3 Paper

    ReplyDelete
  7. Very disappointed in the machine....cannot just use part of a cycle and I have always washed only using cold water. If I just need to spin a load I cannot. the machine is extremely disappointing! When you pay top dollar you expect the best.

    ReplyDelete
  8. same with us. Its a joke. You spend half your time rebalancing it to the point now it doesnt even work it goes out of balance in 30 seconds

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lint on all clothes even after the third wash of the same clothes...extremely disappointed.

    ReplyDelete
  10. We have had our machine for about 5 years with very little problems, in my opinion don't bother with the eco option as it wont wash very well unless you only do 1/2 loads then it is ok, also make sure you use the machines spirit level to make sure that it is level that way it wont go out of balance as often, our one has only gone out of balance about 3 to 4 times in the last 5 years and ours gets used a lot as we are a family of 8 and it literally washes every thing even school bags and shoes etc.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Where is the timer? I have to load the clothes in the morning before I go to work, and put it on the timer, so the clothes are not wet all day. I hate this washer. There is also a seam in the drum of the washer. It looks like it is rusting already! It took me a week to get it from Lowe's. I didn't know the washer was made in OH. Then, the delivery people delivered it at 9:30pm! Had to take a vacation day to wait for the delivery people, who said they would be there first thing in the morning. They called and said they got their truck stuck in the mud, then called again and said they had a mechanical issue with the truck. The store manager of Lowe's in Ann Arbor, MI does not give a crap. Poor service. Offered nothing. I was up late because of the washer, and now am tired for work today. I hate the washer, and will never go to Lowe's again. Maybe the washer will be like a cat. The more you hate it, the longer it lives.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Okay, I have to redeem the manager at the Lowe's in Ann Arbor. He is taking care of the F&P washer problems.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Balance issues, "not getting any water" errors, and more. This thing is a pc of crap. Will never buy F&P appliances again!

    ReplyDelete
  14. We have had our machine now for 4 years, and its been good machine. Our problems started about a month ago with out of balance problems ( slowly getting worst , day by day). Went on a lot of sites to get the run down on if we bought a LEMON or not ? Now if we had of listen to the people that have written so much about this machine in stead of really sitting down and reading the manual ,I think you would get a better understanding on how this machine works. ( and we would have bought another brand other than than this one ). Yes you have to be selective on which cloths you put in together lint wise, yes you have to use the right detergent. Well apart from that and the out of balance , every now and then its not a bad machine. Anyway getting back to my out of balance problem, we got a F & P guy out ( $135.00 before he lifts a spanner ). Now I thought this was a bit steep , but hey if it fixes the problem well then we are all happy. The guy that came out was a great guy that new his job. He was here for 20 min and fixed the problem. $70.00 plus the good old GST plus the service call and the machine is back to were we left it. The guy said this is a common fault with these machines. He replaced the 4 wire rods (shock absorbers ) down the corners of the tub. Now happy wife, happy life . like I said great machine give it a go, if some you do does not work try something or someway different. don't keep blaming the machine, and don't forget to read the manual.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very disappointed with this machine. Always going out of balance

    ReplyDelete
  16. I can't wait for this heap to blow up unfortunately I have extended warrant go back to a Simpson . Retro fit a pylon may help

    ReplyDelete